At the end of more than four and a half hours of escalating drama inside the world’s biggest tennis stadium, a devastated Alex Michelsen fell into Frances Tiafoe’s arms just outside the tramlines, sobbing uncontrollably. Tiafoe took his younger countryman in an embrace and held him there, the victor consoling the vanquished in the aftermath of an extraordinary comeback that had carried him, somehow, into the US Open semi-finals.
Only a couple of hours earlier, the 28-year-old Tiafoe had been two sets down and two points from elimination in the third set, with Michelsen seemingly bound for the biggest victory of his young career. Instead, Tiafoe roared back from the brink to win a quarter-final that will be long remembered in New York, defeating Michelsen 5-7, 3-6, 7-5, 6-3, 7-6 (6) on Tuesday afternoon to reach the last four at Flushing Meadows for the third time in five years.
The contest unfolded inside a half-empty Arthur Ashe Stadium amid an oddly subdued atmosphere for an all-American quarter-final, with many spectators taking a break after Aryna Sabalenka’s grueling three-set win over Linda Noskova in the day’s opener. The setting was hardly ideal for the 11th-seeded Tiafoe, who had played all four previous rounds in the more intimate cauldron of Louis Armstrong Stadium next door, where he thrives on the crowd’s energy and has yet to lose in 10 career matches.
“Everyone was asleep in the first couple hours, and I was like, ‘What’s going on?’” Tiafoe told the Ashe crowd afterwards. “I was asleep with y’all. And then, as it went along, the energy was incredible, as it always is.”
For much of the day it was Michelsen, the unseeded 22-year-old from the Orange County suburb of Laguna Hills, about halfway between Los Angeles and San Diego, who appeared bound for the signature win of a career that has come spectacularly into bloom over the past 10 days. The opening set lurched through four breaks in the first five games before Michelsen was first to find his footing. Tiafoe fought off a set point at 4-5, only for Michelsen to hold at love before pouncing again at 6-5, breaking his opponent’s serve to close out the set after 50 minutes.
Michelsen tightened his grip early in the second as Tiafoe continued to play from behind on his serve, falling behind in five of his first seven service games and getting broken three times. Michelsen broke for 3-1, fought off two break points to consolidate, then broke again for 5-1 after getting the best of a punishing 24-shot exchange before serving out the set. So far, so good.
The match appeared in hand after Michelsen broke again early in the third, eased through his service games and survived a gut-check eighth game, where he fell behind love-40 but calmly brushed aside all three break points before holding for 5-3, including the second with a 134mph ace. One hold of serve from becoming the first American man to reach the last four at the US Open without dropping a set since Jim Courier in 1991, the nerves finally surfaced as Michelsen opened with back-to-back double faults before Tiafoe broke to level at 5-all.
Thrown a lifeline and suddenly energized, Tiafoe held for 6-5, then pressed again as Michelsen served to force a tiebreak. Michelsen saved one set point with a 133mph ace, but Tiafoe manufactured another and this time Michelsen cracked, missing a forehand volley to hand Tiafoe the set 7-5 and drag the match into a fourth.
By now the near-capacity crowd was back in their seats and the complexion of the match had changed completely. Tiafoe had ended the third on a heater, peeling off 17 of the last 22 points, and rode it into the fourth, breaking early as his movement sharpened, the forehand began doing more damage and the Ashe crowd buzzed at the possibility of a comeback.
Michelsen, remarkably composed for most of the afternoon, suddenly looked downcast and occasionally panicked, making 16 unforced errors in the fourth and at one point gently tossing his racket toward the court in frustration. He broke back for 3-2 after a bruising 14-point game, but Tiafoe, now playing with the freedom of a man gifted second life, immediately broke again and held firm from there, serving out the set to force a decider.
The fifth produced the best tennis of the match, both men hitting more winners than unforced errors as the quality somehow rose into the fifth hour. Michelsen regrouped first, breaking Tiafoe at love for 2-0 and consolidating for 3-0, only for Tiafoe to break back shortly after and restore parity. From there neither man yielded. Tiafoe, who had managed only three aces through four sets, uncorked seven of them in the fifth, including three in the final four points of a tense hold for 5-all. Michelsen recovered from love-30 in the next game, prevailing in a 19-shot exchange at 30-all before holding for 6-5. Tiafoe answered once more to force a deciding first-to-10-points tiebreaker, where the pressure only intensified and his greater experience and nerve management finally told.
Tiafoe opened a 6-4 lead in before Michelsen clawed back within a point, but a 135mph ace gave Tiafoe an 8-6 cushion and a Michelsen backhand error brought up three match points. Michelsen saved the first, only for Tiafoe to finish the job on the next with a forehand passing-shot winner, sealing the victory after 4hr 38min. Tiafoe briefly gestured to roaring crowd before quickly finding his opponent in front of the umpire’s chair, while Michelsen was quickly overcome by tears and eventually walked off Ashe with a dark blue towel pulled over his head.
“Obviously, a tough game,” Tiafoe said. “He gave me some gifts, a couple double faults there, but then I slowly, slowly started to get my rhythm there, snuck out that third set and only started playing better and better. And he’s a hell of a player, man. I mean, he easily could have won today.”
The victory continued a remarkable fortnight for Tiafoe, whose momentum has steadily gathered pace since finding himself two sets to one down against Martin Damm in the opening round. After straight-sets victories over Rei Sakamoto, Valentin Vacherot and seventh-seeded Daniil Medvedev, he found himself staring at an even deeper hole on Tuesday before producing the third comeback from two sets down of his career.
It also marked another milestone in Tiafoe’s enduring love affair with the US Open. The Maryland native, who first reached the semi-finals here in 2022 before returning to the same stage two years later, became only the second American man this century to reach three US Open semi-finals along with Andre Agassi.
For Michelsen, the defeat brought a brutal end to the deepest grand slam run of his young career. The world No 46 had not dropped a set through four rounds, knocking out the 16th seed Brandon Nakashima and 27th seed Tomas Martín Etcheverry while becoming the first man born in 2004 to reach a major quarter-final. On Tuesday, he came within two points of carrying that flawless run all the way to the semi-finals.
Tiafoe will face the winner of Tuesday night’s quarter-final between Carlos Alcaraz and Ben Shelton on Friday, with a place in his first grand slam final at stake.
